Safest Towns in Long Island, NY

Those planning to move to Long Island may be looking for the best of both worlds: a waterfront suburban lifestyle adjacent to the hustle and bustle of the nearby metropolis.
In addition to finding this balance, one of the major considerations in deciding where exactly in Long Island you'll be moving to is often safety. This may be at the top of your location checklist, regardless of whether you're making the move on your own or with a family.
This guide will help you identify the safest towns on Long Island and why. From crime rates to family friendly amenities, we've got all the information you need to make an informed decision.
Article Summary
- The safest towns on Long Island include Brookhaven, Huntington, Islip, Great Neck, and Massapequa.
- When choosing a neighborhood, consider safety, amenities, proximity to work or schools, and your budget.
- These towns offer a mix of suburban charm, recreational opportunities, and excellent schools, making them ideal for families and professionals alike.
- Each town features unique attractions, such as beaches, cultural venues, and historical landmarks.
- All of these towns provide a calm, community oriented environment that can be perfect for those seeking a peaceful suburban lifestyle.
- Whether you're moving across Long Island or coming from the city, Piece of Cake Moving & Storage handles everything from packing and COIs to on demand storage, so you can settle into your new, safe Long Island town seamlessly.
What to Consider When Choosing the Best Safe Towns in Long Island
As you prioritize safety in your quest for moving to the right town, take some time to consider several important factors that also play a role in making a decision:
Safety: Look at crime statistics, including property and violent crimes. This will help you assess whether a neighborhood is a safe place to live on Long Island.
Amenities: Are there parks, schools, shopping centers, or recreational activities nearby?
Budget: Determine if the cost of living in the safest neighborhoods on Long Island is within your range.
Commute: If you work in NYC, you may want to move to a town that offers easy access to the city via public transportation or major highways.
Five of the Safest Towns in Long Island, NY
While Long Island's Suffolk and Nassau Counties publish crime statistics in different formats, the following list of towns reports some of the lowest crime numbers on the island.
What you'll notice is that these towns share a few commonalities. They're largely residential areas with plenty of recreational options – and some unique spots all their own.
For those who are hoping to find the right balance of city and suburban living while prioritizing safety, these Long Island towns are worth looking into.
1. Brookhaven, Suffolk County
The Town of Brookhaven, the only one in Suffolk County to stretch to both the north and south shores, is the most heavily populated town in the county. It's situated about 50 miles from Manhattan.
For its size, there's a lot going on in this neck of the woods, including two major locations. One is the Brookhaven National Laboratory, which runs several nuclear, physics, neuroscience, and environmental programs on behalf of the U.S. Department of Energy. The other is Stony Brook University. So, if you find yourself working at or attending these institutions, you may decide to make yourself at home here.
Southaven County Park has a wealth of ways to spend your time, from hiking, camping, fishing, rowboating, and hunting. Covering over 1,300 acres of pine-oak forest, the Carmans River runs through this scenic space. The numerous beaches in this part of Long Island are well known for surfing conditions, sailing, swimming, and fishing. For recreation options on land, you can check out what the Brookhaven Arts and Humanities Council has cooking. They host a number of events, including the annual Brookhaven Choral Festival, as well as gallery exhibitions and workshops for all ages.
2. Huntington, Suffolk County
This town on Long Island's North Shore is known for its suburban feel and proximity to Manhattan.
For those who are looking to reside in Long Island but commute to the city, there are Long Island Railroad (LIRR) stops nearby in Northport and Cold Spring Harbor, and bus service throughout town from the Huntington Area Rapid Transit. For those commuting by personal vehicle, there are several major roads accessible to get you where you need to go, including the Northern State Parkway and the Long Island Expressway.
If you're hoping to explore what the town has to offer, the good news is that there's plenty. The Paramount Theatre is a great place to see live performances from major musical and comedy acts. Another well known gem in the town is the historical Oheka Castle. This Gold Coast mansion turned hotel is on the National Registry of Historic Places and has been the backdrop for a number of TV and film productions, including Citizen Kane.
If you're relocating from one of the five boroughs, you may be worried that you won't be as close to celebrated art as you once were. Fret not, the Heckscher Museum of Art is worth a visit to appreciate world-renowned and local artistic talent. And if you're hoping to make a night of it in the town, you'll be happy to know there's a range of cuisines and price ranges to choose from in the area restaurants.
3. Islip, Suffolk County
Along Long Island's south shore, you'll find the third largest town in the state, comprising four villages and twenty-four hamlets.
With many marinas along the Great South Bay, you'll find several ferry and water taxi services to get you to and from the island. If your travels take you farther out, Islip is also home to the MacArthur Airport (ISP), and it serves about 2 million people per year.
When your schedule has you sticking close to home, though, you won't be at a loss for things to do. Pencil in some time to make a visit to the historic Fire Island Light House, with a timeline that dates back to the mid-1800s. It's also the site of the annual Keepers Craft Tasting event for beer aficionados. For history buffs who can't get enough of the landmarks and accounts of their new hometown, you can also make your way through the Historic Islip Trail. There are also a number of green spaces and recreational areas in town, including the Central Islip Recreation Center and Casamento Pool. For those who live to putt on the green, there are also several golf courses in the area, Gull Haven Golf Course being one of them.
4. Great Neck, Nassau County
With its waterfront views and access on the north shore of the island, you'll begin to appreciate why this setting was the purported inspiration for F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby. As it stands now, it is a part of Long Island that has a relaxed, suburban feel away from the hustle and bustle of NYC.
This diverse and family oriented area has more homeowners than renters, and the housing options vary, with a mix of bungalows, Tudor-style, and colonial-style homes. However, there are also apartments and condos for rent.
In terms of commuting, you can take the LIRR from the Great Neck Station, and you'll be at Penn Station in about 30-40 minutes, depending on your departure time. For the times you plan to be in town, you'll appreciate what Great Neck has to offer its residents. Parkwood Sports Complex boasts a number of pools, tennis courts, and even an ice rink. You can still enjoy a cultural experience right where you are, at the Great Neck House, which hosts concerts, art classes, and movie nights.
To take advantage of the nearby waters, you can set sail at the marina in Steppingstone Park in the Long Island Sound – or you can learn how to sail at the Steppingstone Sailing School. If being at the helm of the boat isn't for you, the park has other amenities, including playgrounds and picnic areas. And though you won't be too far away from the retail options in the city, the town's Lakewood Road has plenty of restaurants and shops to find your next treasure or pick up a few necessities.
5. Massapequa, Nassau County
There's very much a community vibe amongst the suburban sprawl in this town along Long Island's south shore.
Within its bounds, you're likely to find a number of different style homes, including colonial-style, craftsman-style, and Tudor-style houses, many of which have porches.
It's been said that some of the best parks are located in this part of Long Island and there are a lot of them. A visit to John J. Burns Park may lead you to a tennis match or to enjoying a performance in their summer concert line up. The town is also home to the Field of Dreams Park, which may sound familiar because it's the one named after the Hollywood movie. Though it doesn't have a baseball diamond, it does have turf that allows the same grounds to be used for a number of different sports.
If your cravings or other reasons take you beyond the bounds of this town, you may be looking at a longer commute into the city, around an hour or so on the LIRR or driving from this starting point.
Thinking About Moving to One of Long Island's Safest Towns?
If you're trading in city living for the Long Island life, you'll be happy you partnered with the professionals at Piece of Cake Moving & Storage for your next move. As the #1 top rated moving experts, we're well prepared to move you from any part of the city to your new suburban home. Our team of moving experts understands the details, timing, and transit logistics that come with moving to Long Island. Whether you're moving to one of these safest neighborhoods on Long Island or another area, we've got you covered.
Get your guaranteed All-inclusive Flat Fee Quote today, and leave the hassle of packing and moving to us. You can focus on settling into your new neighborhood while we handle all the logistics from start to finish.

















